Leaking Balcony Scenario (Top-Floor Veranda Tiles)
A specific scenario was asked: If a unit is on the top level and the tiles of a veranda are leaking into the same unit, who is responsible for sealing and repairs?
So in the case of a top-floor unit’s veranda (balcony) leaking: the body corporate is responsible for fixing the underlying cause of the leak, i.e. repairing or resealing the waterproofing membrane and any related structural elements. The body corporate would likely need to engage contractors to remove the tiles, apply new waterproofing, and reinstate the tiles or surface to ensure the leak is resolved. This is considered a part of the building’s structural maintenance.
Meanwhile, the lot owner is responsible for maintaining the visible surfaces and finishes of the balcony as part of their lot. For example, keeping the balcony clean, ensuring the grout is in decent condition, and not doing anything to damage the waterproofing (like drilling into the floor) is the owner’s duty. However, an owner would not be expected to fix a failing balcony membrane on their own, because that membrane serves as protection for the lower parts of the building – it’s the body corporate’s job to maintain it. If the leak from the balcony causes damage inside the unit (say to the ceiling of the room below, or to the interior of the same unit), the body corporate’s responsibility typically extends to repairing that damage as well, because it resulted from a failure of a body corporate-maintained element. (Often, body corporate insurance may cover resulting water damage to unit interiors from such leaks.)
In summary: For a leaking top-floor balcony, the body corporate must address the leak by repairing the balcony’s waterproofing (and any structural repair needed), whereas the lot owner should cooperate by maintaining their balcony’s surface and not causing the issue. The owner might handle minor tile maintenance, but full re-sealing or structural fixes fall on the body corporate. The Act makes it clear the body corporate has this duty so that the building remains structurally sound and water-tight. (Note: If the leak was caused by something the owner did – for example, an owner tiled over the original membrane incorrectly, or failed to keep drains from clogging – the body corporate might fix it but could potentially seek the cost from the owner due to their negligence. But if it’s normal wear-and-tear or building defect, it’s squarely a body corporate issue.)